While at first glance the title might lead you to believe that this two day
outing to Biosphere 2 was thought-provoking but generally
dull, but this assumption would be only half right. The
experience was both thought provoking and very entertaining.
Day one began with an exploration of medical ethics
and acknowledgement of the fact that concisely defining
ethics is a nearly impossible task. The small group activity,
which followed, allowed individuals to question their
own ethics and determine how they would act when posed
with the dilemma of killing one patient to possibly save
another. By providing a wide of variety of endings to
the scenario, it was emphasized that we often have no
way of knowing what the ultimate outcome may be when
making an ethical decision.
The afternoon was filled with a discussion on human
rights and, for many, an introduction to the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights. Small groups again met to
examine problems that society faces and how human rights
are associated with these problems. Our last formal discussion
of the day was an examination of different views on environmental
ethics and how they are present in current governmental
policy.
In order to be better prepared for the Biosphere 2 tour,
Matt Adamson, Biosphere 2 Program Coordinator,
explained the complicated history of the place as well
as the cult-like nature of the eight original biospherians. Though
the weather was dreary, the evening progressed with a
viewing of The Fountain followed by a hilarious game
of the 1980s version of Scruples. Laughter carried on
for hours as we all grew closer through answers of "yes,
no, or depends" to a multitude of ethical dilemmas.
Our second and final day began with our official Biosphere
2 tour complete with an eccentric tour guide emphasizing
the fact that "we can make it rain 24 hours a day,
seven days a week," although we were all wondering
when she would deem herself all powerful. Nonetheless,
Biosphere 2 was spectacular from the rainforest, to the
lung, to the grounds themselves, and in my opinion, if
you're already in Tucson; it's not to be missed.
The final and perhaps most entertaining portion of the
retreat began with an introduction to professional and
research ethics by Dr. Frans Tax, Molecular & Cellular
Biology. This covered everything from the laboratory
hierarchy to what you should and should not do during
your first week of work. Once all four discussions of
ethics were complete, each small group presented a humorous
skit of one form or another recapping each of the topics.
They ranged from ethics jeopardy to an especially hilarious
skit about medical ethics and drug companies providing
gifts to doctors in hopes they will overlook drug side
effects such as "tracheal mere cat colonies" and "death."
All in all, it was a wonderful experience that undoubtedly
was the highlight of UBRP outings for the summer. Not
only did we get to know all of our peers better, but
also the ethics retreat allowed each of us to know ourselves
and understand our beliefs better.
Katherine Teter, UBRPer in Dr. Alan Nighorn's lab, ARL-
Neurobiology